I’ve always been a sucker for RPG games. When I’m feeling down I tend to play Final Fantasy 8 or Final Fantasy 10, they’re like my comfort games.

I’ve had a hard time finding joy in modern RPG games, they all feel very grindy and seem to have an uninteresting plot. I’m looking for something that sparks joy, so I don’t have look for some ridiculous challenge like Khimari only run in FF10 or something.

Things that spark joy:

  • Being able to play on Steam Deck or at least stream from my (linux) desktop
  • Decent graphics, though pixel art is ok
  • Voice acting
  • No random encounters
  • Good plot
  • Good combat

Things that do not spark joy:

  • Too much grinding
  • DnD mechanics
  • Mandatory online requirement

Games that I really enjoyed:

  • Final Fantasy 7 through 10
  • Final Fantasy 5
  • Dragon Quest XI
  • Xenoblade Chronicles 1/2
  • South Park games
  • Stardew Valley

Games that I did not enjoy:

  • Elden Ring - I guess I just don’t have the mental patience for souls games anymore.
  • Final Fantasy X-2 - great combat mechanics, horrendous plot
  • “Modern” Final Fantasy games
  • Divinity: Original Sin 2, Disco Elysium - feels too much like DnD
  • Hogwarts Legacy - It felt amazing at first but then got super repetitive
  • Persona 5 Royal - The game severely overstayed its welcome, very bloated, very repetitive dialog (the characters tell you the same information multiple times)
  • I am Setsuna - The plot resembled Final Fantasy 10 way too much, felt like I had already played that game. Didn’t finish
  • Kingdom Hearts - Severe motion sickness
  • Octopath Traveler - The plot felt extremely disconnected, random encounters were annoying, I got stuck due to an underleveled party and didn’t have the patience to grind it up

Thanks in advance!

  • pathief@lemmy.worldOPEnglish
    1·
    4 days ago

    I played it recently-ish but didn’t enjoy it. There are a lot of characters and the story is constantly moving between them. I didn’t enjoy that.

    • Coelacanth@feddit.nuEnglish
      2·
      4 days ago

      Interesting, it’s my absolute favourite personally. I don’t hear many people dislike it.

      On the subject of pixel art retro styled RPGs though I want to make a case for Skald: Against the Black Priory. It doesn’t have voice acting, but otherwise should satisfy your demands given you say you tolerate pixel art. It’s very short for an RPG (16-20h) but that also means it’s very concise, has no filler and no grinding. Should play well on a Steam Deck too. I played it back in January I think and had an absolute blast with it. Cool story and world building, fun somewhat simple combat. Very enjoyable.

      EDIT: though there is some dice rolling in dialogue, so maybe that’s a no go.

      • pathief@lemmy.worldOPEnglish
        2·
        4 days ago

        I don’t hear many people dislike it.

        I know it’s a totally unpopular opinion, I know FF6 is often rated as the best one of the series. Just didn’t click for me.

        I’ll check out ot Skald, thanks!