Yeah, this is news to me. I think Codeberg runs on Forgejo, and just the other day people were singing its praises when GitHub became part of Microsoft’s AI team. This feels like a sudden shift.
I wouldn’t call that “seething”, the project is targeting an English speaking audience (English is the source, other languages are translation targets), effectively no one is a native speaker of Esperanto, and it’s usage is small enough that someone could quite possibly never encounter the language.
Bad project names are common enough in programming and open source, and complained about, that I wouldn’t jump right to xenophobia as the reason someone might complain that a project picked a name knowing it would be difficult to pronounce.
They can name it whatever they want, but getting that angry that someone didn’t recognize a word in an anglisiced spelling of a word from a niche language is uncalled for.
Ubuntu: Super marketable, everyone can pronounce it, no confusion, easily understandable by four language knowing people
Gentoo: So easy to remember, marketing geniuses
Godot: Inpossible to pronounce incorrectly. Children are born knowing how to say it. Exemplars of universal human communication.
Forgejo: What were they even thinking? So bad. Who can even understand it without a dedicated audio file? People who know four languages struggle with it. A failure.
Personally uaong forgejo myself and it has been smooth sailing for ages! This is the first time ive ever seen people taking a stance against it, though the ones in the comments sidnt seem to have a good argument.
I guess I’m out of the loop: why do ppl hate forgejo?
I’ve never seen anyone hate on forgejo.
Why do you think prople hate Forgejo?
They probably don’t. If you see a sudden FUD, it could be astroturfing.
Probably just the weird name. It makes it feel like someone’s weekend personal project.
I use it to self-host my own code and it works great, I’m totally moved off GitHub now.
Yeah, this is news to me. I think Codeberg runs on Forgejo, and just the other day people were singing its praises when GitHub became part of Microsoft’s AI team. This feels like a sudden shift.
Another git repository that is not hosted on itself?
Seems like a weird choice.
That’s like the CEO from Microsoft going on stage with a MacBook.
Forgejo is developped on Codeberg, which runs on Forgejo
Codeberg is the “demo” Forgejo instance is where they develop the software (Forgejo)
Forgejo is a fork of Gitea which is pretty well known. They forked out of fear because Gitea got bought and is now a for-profit iirc
Codeberg is a service. Forgejo is a platform.
It’s more like how a warehouse company doesn’t build its own forklifts.
Wasnt aware of that. I believed they were an alternative to gitea, github, forgejo, sourceforge
Codeberg is a forgejo installation. lemmy.dbzer0.com isn’t lemmy itself
I don’t even know how to pronounce it. Forge Joe? For Gay Ho?
For-j-o
https://forgejo.org/static/forgejo.mp4
Any product name that needs a voice file to explain itself is a bad name 🤦 what were they thinking?
I have some bad new for you about Linux…
I hadn’t heard that before, but that is exactly how I also pronounce it 😍
source
Let me guess: You think everyone needs to speak english?
Imagine seething at words in a language you don’t speak because you don’t speak it
I wouldn’t call that “seething”, the project is targeting an English speaking audience (English is the source, other languages are translation targets), effectively no one is a native speaker of Esperanto, and it’s usage is small enough that someone could quite possibly never encounter the language.
Bad project names are common enough in programming and open source, and complained about, that I wouldn’t jump right to xenophobia as the reason someone might complain that a project picked a name knowing it would be difficult to pronounce.
They can name it whatever they want, but getting that angry that someone didn’t recognize a word in an anglisiced spelling of a word from a niche language is uncalled for.
Your assumptions betray you. I speak 4 languages fluently/natively and two-three more poorly. English is not my native language.
This is not about language, but about marketing. Thank you.
“i, in all of my infinite wisdom and knowledge, knower of four languages, cant pronounce word therefore bad marketing” 😭
seriously why do you care so much about the marketing ability of a foss tool? they arent selling it?
Seems to me that you are the seething one, not me. Taking a walk might improve your mood.
Ubuntu: Super marketable, everyone can pronounce it, no confusion, easily understandable by four language knowing people
Gentoo: So easy to remember, marketing geniuses
Godot: Inpossible to pronounce incorrectly. Children are born knowing how to say it. Exemplars of universal human communication.
Forgejo: What were they even thinking? So bad. Who can even understand it without a dedicated audio file? People who know four languages struggle with it. A failure.
We can name things Forge in English, but not in a different language without your criticism?
Rijndael is pronounced AES.
Personally uaong forgejo myself and it has been smooth sailing for ages! This is the first time ive ever seen people taking a stance against it, though the ones in the comments sidnt seem to have a good argument.