A common situation in my life is the following: a small-ish organization consisting of somewhere from 3 to 50 people need some type of way to be reached as a group. The current solution is to have an email adress, normally with a password that is shared in some way among the trusted subset of members that need to be able to access the email directly.

The solution isn’t great for multiple reasons:

  • Sharing a password among multiple people isn’t great, 2FA is tricky
  • Most email communication are readable by the email provider, unless PGP is correctly used. For most people, PGP is non-trivial to use correctly, and meta-data will not be encrypted even with correctly used PGP.

But it has the following upsides:

  • A single stable address to reach the group
  • Communication is gathered in one place, searchable, possible to for multiple members to track communication with someone that has reached out.
  • Easy to use from any device anywhere

Ideally we’d like all of these things: sensible access controls, some level of transparency within the org regarding who has responded to what messages, an address that is easy to share with people outside the group, minimal (meta)data accessible by the providers, and easy to use across devices.

How do you handle this? What would your recommendation be? I have considered setting up a Signal account, but having multiple signal accounts on a single device is non-trivial, as is setting it up on a new device, meaning that probably each group would need a single dedicated device, which isn’t super practical.

  • umami_wasabi@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    3 hours ago

    Say your organization is doing something like Amnesty International (at least sounds awlful lot similar to me), you want a solution that

    • encryption
    • shared inbox between trusted members
    • minimal meta-data leak to providers (service providers and network node operators)
      • hide who is sending/receiving
    • easy to search/indexed
    • fine grained access control
    • audit log of who responed to who
    • multi-device
    • single stable address/contact point (hoe “stable” you need it to be?)
    • 2fa?
    • easy to use

    Am I correct? To be honest, it is quite a tall order. I can’t really think of a solution right now. Email is definitely out of the question because you can’t hide who is sending and receiving the email.